Skip to content
Urban Ideas

My Plan to Reform the Academy Structure and Assist Youth Talent

Among the favourite occasions from this campaign occurred the other day, viewing a young talent surge forward from his own box to seal a clinching strike.

Homegrown prospects are always celebrated by their club's supporters and, from what I've seen, the faithful are set to enjoy many more special displays from him in the seasons to come.

However, for each player who makes it, there are countless of other youngsters who don't make it through the different levels, and are forced to deal with a devastating setback at a formative age.

It is these players who fall away of academy football that are my focus, because I don't think the current setup does enough to advise them about their prospects, or support them when they are released.

It requires an overhaul and, after I stepped away, I authored my own report into the academy system, featuring recommendations for how it could be bettered.

An Huge Commitment – Yielding Some Substantial Benefits

My outlook on youth setups is not just as a ex- coach. My family members are in the system, so I've got a direct interest too.

For all young footballers, the dream of becoming a professional player is a unique one. The youth development framework has been created to give them the greatest chance to realise that dream, with a dedicated programme being launched over a decade ago.

Currently, many thousands of boys are in the system, at clubs from the Premier League down. It's an demanding structure, with coaching no less than three nights a week and a fixtures schedule that consumes most of their weekends.

The similar programme is now being adopted by the rapidly expanding sport, women's football, too.

These academies are manned at high levels and offer work for trainers, physios, doctors and many more administrative staff.

The amenities are of the best level, with excellent indoor and outdoor pitches. Academic study is provided too, with tutors employed to run compulsory educational programmes.

The investment is vast but, as we have witnessed, the clubs at the pinnacle are gaining substantial benefits on that outlay through loans and transfers of the academy-produced players.

How is the Existing Plan?

The key performance programme has been in place for nearly 15 years now, so how has it performed to the scrutiny of time?

Academies now run a pre-academy programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them finish the entire programme they would graduate at 21. That's longer than a child spends in compulsory education, and lasts his entire childhood.

These children are issued with team uniform and jackets, all branded up, and are recognised by peers and relatives as being associated with that club.

Their identity has, in essence, been etched on them at a young age and they also have to make a total dedication to the academy schedule.

That means coaching on three evenings a week, and a fixtures programme lasting most of the weekend, are now a key component of a young player's quest to follow his ambition.

From my research, in a lot of cases what happens at school is seen as being secondary, with the academy assuming primary importance and turning into the main concern of the child and his parents' life.

A number of families see a financial reward at the end of the rainbow if their child succeeds and place enormous pressure on their backs to make it.

Regrettably, statistics show the system has a profound imbalance of success and failure. We all see the ones who make it, but we seldom acknowledge those who fail.

Be Frank About Their Chances

I have no desire to take those dreams away from young players but we need to be honest with them about their chances.

While there are certain talents a club will pinpoint as being future professionals, the fact is a significant proportion of the youngsters have only been on the programme to occupy the places needed for coaching and the weekend fixtures at each age group.

I really think academies properly set the understandings of these players or families, about where they sit in the broader structure.

Players and parents should be given a full breakdown of where they rate, so they can manage for the inevitable disappointment when it comes.

Our academies have produced some exceptional players and there is increased attention paid to player care now than in the past, but let's also introduce a bit more priority on transparency too.

More Priority on Education

As I mentioned above, I believe many youngsters joining academies actually listen more closely of their coaches at times than they do of their teachers.

It's important this is recognised within the academy system, and youth directors impart this principle to the coaches at each age group.

This phenomenon itself is long-standing. Tutelage played a significant part in my upbringing, and PE teachers and coaches were always held in high regard.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must ensure the coaches are given unambiguous instructions and appreciation of their role because of the sway they have.

Levels of decorum, conduct and hard work should be as high as they are in any school environment – and should relate to the educational side of the child's life there too.

The framework I have proposed would have greater weight on academics and counselling – for parents as well as the young players – and also support for what happens next if they are dropped aged 16.

My Proposal to Help Young Players

I would place academies within a number of zones, each run by a head and partner them with approved schools and colleges.

Prior to they get to apprenticeship level, players would be reviewed at 14 to see what learning pathway fits them.

At 16, players starting apprenticeships would enrol in a compulsory dual academic programme with the academic partners.

At the same time, the players who are let go at 16, can start a full-time dual learning programme with the schools or colleges.

The positive for them would be the establishment of a new competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

By

Ann Miller

Urban planner and sustainability advocate with over a decade of experience in community development projects across major cities.

Urban Ideas

Type to search articles.